Her weight was 76kg in July 2019 when she went through a pre-employment medical check-up mandated by the Ministry of Manpower (MOM). Some of the other things Zariah did included not allowing Ms Khanifah to call home or use the phone, and barring her from speaking to the neighbours. Before meting out the sentence, Senior District Judge Bala Reddy said he found it aggravating that the victim had been put through humiliating and degrading punishments that ultimately resulted in, among other things, her becoming irreversibly blind. The prosecutors said: The kick was painful and she could still feel the pain after five days.. All rights reserved | Terms & Conditions | Data Protection Policy | Advertise with us. Download from the Apple App Storeor Google Play Store now. The then 40-year-old had poked her Indonesian maid, Ms Tardem, all over her head and slapped both sides of her face in August 2012, reported The Straits Times. Judge Reddy also pointed out that the harm Ummi caused to the victim was not just physical, but also psychological. The boiling water was punishment for Ms Badingah's alleged mistreatment of Masselly's younger daughter. By registering, you agree to our T&C and Privacy Policy. Defence lawyer Sui Yi Siong of Harry Elias Partnership sought a jail term of six years and six months for his client, saying that as Ummi is a homemaker who takes care of her relatively young children while her husband works in shifts, an enhanced jail time would impose significant hardship on her. He did not say anything to her before he committed the offence, the court heard. Between April 2020 and September 2020, Ummi continued hitting both of the victims eyes, despite knowing that she had completely lost vision in her right eye. Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you. A housewife forced her Indonesian domestic helper to shower with the toilet door open and get dressed in front of open windows. As punishment, Wong pulled down the Ms Rinonos' shorts and panties to her feet in front of her children. The court heard that he is not facing any charges. Tan Huat began serving his sentence on Tuesday. Ms Yulianti started working for the family in January 2012. Ms Sha was able to mediate between the pair and ensure it did not happen again. Copyright 2023 SPH Media Limited. The couple also threatened to send the maid to Batam to become a prostitute. Here are some of the worst maid abusers from the last 10 years. His wife was also pleaded guilty to the charge of maid abuse. All rights reserved. In response to queries from The Straits Times, the police said they received a call for assistance at 2.19pm at Block 415 Sembawang Drive. Published by SPH Media Limited, Co. Regn. When Ms Sugiyem attempted to shield her eyes from the blows, Ummi grabbed and pulled down one of her hands and continued to punch both the maids eyes. Tan Lee Hoon, 58, kicked one of them as the helper . The gift link for this subscriber-only article has expired. 202120748H. Ms Yulia took the opportunity to escape with her belongings when Ong later left the flat with her son. Published by SPH Media Limited, Co. Regn. During the trial, he claimed that Ms Emi had inflicted the injuries on herself. Deepakala later hit the maids right arm and back with a stick. But the judge rejected Mr Singh's suggestion on Thursday, noting that Ong's depressed state at that time did not justify her use of violence on the victim. After slapping the victim, Huat told the victim that if Ai Tee or Pei Ling was talking to her, she had to reply instead of keeping quiet. She also burned her with a heated iron and choked her. The prosecutors said: The accused then took a nearly depleted roll of masking tape and hit the victims forehead with it.. The other maid used a calling gesture to suggest alerting the authorities for help. We are glad that there are laws in place to protect our MDWs.". "If not, she would beat her with (a stick) and throw her out of the window. She was later sentenced to an extra three months imprisonment after she was found guilty in a separate trial of hitting the same victims back twice with a foldable chair. The gift link for this subscriber-only article has expired. During the trial, Ms Lizardo testified that Tan had hit her many times between October 2015 and October 2018. During the same incident in April 2020, Ummi also directly punched both of the victims eyes repeatedly. The 24-year-old Myanmar national died on July 26, 2016. Deepakala, who is represented by lawyer Kalaithasan Karuppaya, denied hitting Ms Eni. Zariah Mohd Ali was sentenced to 11 years' jail while her husband Mohamad Dahlan was sentenced to 15 months' jail for his role in the abuse. A woman was enraged when her domestic worker said she wanted to quit and rained blows on her head and body as she sobbed on the floor. For two months in 2007, Indonesian maid Ms Badingah, 30, was subjected to what was described as "systematic torture". Noryanti Abdul Rahim, was jailed for three months on two counts of maid abuse. In another incident in August 2016, Ong scolded Ms Yulia for taking her shower later than usual. Ms Heni was taken to hospital with multiple injuries including facial bruises and burn marks. The prosecutors said: She alleged that the victim was upset with her for wanting to send the victim back to her home country, and that the victim was trying to garner sympathy for herself.. Get more of Stomp's latest updates by following us on Facebook, WhatsApp, Twitter, Instagram and YouTube. Chan Yow Kuen, 50, forced her maid's left ring finger into hot oil in March 2005. causing her to permanently lose her sight. She noted thatMOM-appointed officers conduct house visits to randomly selected homes and mandate post-placement checks by employment agencies. According to court documents, she even provided officers at Clementi Police Division with the contact details of some of her other maids in a bid to prove her innocence. He also convicted Tasleem, 41, of two assault charges. Co. Regn. 202120748H. Maid agents believe they can play a vital role in stopping abuse. The maid ran away by climbing through the window of her second-storey flat. The family started abusing Ms Heni soon after. In November 2009,Maselly was jailed for three years. The couple are represented by lawyer Peter Keith Fernando. Al-Hafiz treated her well at first, but three months into her employment, the abuse began. Her weight was 76kg in July 2019 when she went through a pre-employment medical check-up mandated by the Ministry of Manpower (MOM). Over a period of six months, a woman abused her Indonesian domestic helper by punching her repeatedly, and on one occasion using a clothes hanger to hit her eyes,causing her to permanently lose her sight. The domestic worker suffered a nose bleed as a result. The DPPs said the other maid gestured to ask why Ms Eni had bruises on her face, and Ms Eni replied by demonstrating a motion of hitting oneself to indicate her employer had hit her. He urged District Judge Tham to call for a report assessing her suitability for a mandatory treatment order (MTO). Soh had abused her maid from April to May 2009. Domestic helper wins US Best Actress award, Maid arrested for murder came here just months ago, llowed to bathe only once every three days. Ms Sugiyem was also given medical attention in Singapore, but her blindness is irreversible, the court heard. Events manager Tan Pei Ling, who splashed hot coffee on Ms Heni and assaulted her with a heated iron, pleaded guilty to two assault charges. On one occasion, Bai, who was not happy with the way her helper did the laundry, shoved the victim into a storeroom causing her to hit her head against the wall. Ms Sugiyem weighed 52.8kg on February 2021. If people were to ask what happened, she would tell them 'this girl's mental state of mind was not good'.". You have reached your limit of subscriber-only articles this month. She had initially hit her with a bamboo pole on the head, back and thighs. Gaiyathiri Murugayan poured cold water on the victim, Ms Piang Ngaih Don, and slapped, punched and stomped on her. Many also choose to not report abuse out of fear of losing employment.". She appealed her conviction but it was dismissed by the High court in August 2013. In November 2011, Ms Khanifah arrived in Singapore from a village in Indramayu, West Java, to work as a maid for the couple. The prosecution highlighted how Ms Khanifah, in a victim impact statement recorded on July 29, said the abuse left her feeling traumatised. Ummi had installed a closed-circuit television (CCTV) camera in the kitchen in early 2020 to monitor her. Rosdiana Abdul Rahim, 33, also pinched the victim on the right breast, before kicking her twice in the genitals. The housewife continued physically abusing Ms Kaur after this, assaulting her with objects including a broomstick, a shower head, a rolling pin and a pair of tongs. The housewife was angry that her maid Siti Kamsiyah had used too much oil in the frying pan when preparing dinner for the family at her flat in Clementi, reported The Straits Times. The prosecution had called this one of the worst cases of maid abuse in Singapore. DPP Tan also said medical evidence showed that Zariah still has normal functioning and strength in the right side of her body. Another seven charges, including two of voluntarily causing hurt to another maid from Myanmmar, Ms Su Su Han, were taken into consideration during sentencing. Defence lawyer Sui Yi Siong of Harry Elias Partnership sought a jail term of six years and six months for his client, saying that as Ummi is a homemaker who takes care of her relatively young children while her husband works in shifts, an enhanced jail time would impose significant hardship on her. Deepakala Chandra Secharan alleged the maids injuries were self-inflicted. She then jumped to the ground floor, suffering abrasions to one arm, and somehow made her way to her maid agency Nora Employment Agency. Soh Meiyun,34, had her 16-month jail term for abusing her Indonesian maid reduced to a $15,000 fine on appeal. The maid decided to save herself in July 2007 after she got traumatised by the mere action of Maselly switching on the kettle. Published by SPH Media Limited, Co. Regn. Muhamad Al-Hafiz Nordin, 31, was jailed four weeks for causing hurt to his maid, Ms Yulianti, 34. Chan was originally sentenced to 21 months' jail in 2013. The court also heard that Ms Kaur initially had a good relationship with Tasleem and that he was kind to her. The prosecution said Farha Tehseen and her spouse Mohammad Tasleem "lashed out" at Ms Kaur, an Indian national who was then 27, as they saw her as a "poor performer" who "did not meet their standards". During the same incident in April 2020, Ummi also directly punched both of the victims eyes repeatedly. You have reached your limit of subscriber-only articles this month. Get unlimited access to all stories at $0.99/month for the first 3 months. In response to queries from The. She then continued to hit the victim with a clothes hanger until it broke. You have reached your limit of subscriber-only articles this month. SINGAPORE Over a period of six months, a woman abused her Indonesian domestic helper by punching her repeatedly, and on one occasion using a clothes hanger to hit her eyes, causing her to permanently lose her sight. Her daughter Nur Rizan Mohd Sazali was sentenced to two years and two months in jail. He added that on weekdays, the maid would go to bed at around 3am and wake up about two hours later. A doctor who examined Ms Lizardo five days later found that the maid had tenderness over her sternum, consistent with injury inflicted by a kick to the chest. She scolded Ms Heni, grabbed the knife from her right hand and pierced it near the wrist with the sharp tip of the knife, causing the hand to bleed. She also said that Farha later punched her right eye. However, she remembered that in October 2018, Tan was wearing a ring on her finger when she hit the maid hard on the head. Despite observing that Ms Sugiyems ear was swollen, Ummi did not provide any medical aid and did not take her to a doctor. "However, the victim remained standing in front of the accused as one of the rules given by the accused was that she was to stay still when the accused was angry at the victim," Deputy Public Prosecutor Soh Weiqi had said in earlier proceedings. Common queries on helpline calls touch on issues like salary, job scope and termination of employment. The helper lost the vision in her right eye after one of the accuseds punches. Tasleem then punched her right eye once. Mar 29, 2021 06:00 am An average of 270 reports of abuse involving migrant domestic workers (MDWs) were made to the police each year between 2017 and 2020. DPP Johannus said that Farha slapped and punched the maid on the first day she started working for her. This article is now fully available for you, Please verify your e-mail to read this subscriber-only article in full. The abuse was discovered when Ms Khanifah returned to Indonesia in December 2012. She then told Ms Heni to iron all the clothes in the living room and that she would not be allowed to sleep or eat if she failed to complete the task by 5am. Ms Flora Sha, who manages United Channel, conducts a briefing before the maids are deployed and they are told they should call the agency in the event of any abuse. Officers entered the flat and forcibly restrained the pair before arresting them, said the Shin Min report. On one occasion, Zhao slapped the victims cheeks 10 times and said: I will do it until you are really, really scared.. The spokesman added that the ministry will take firm action against those who do not perform their duties as employers of domestic workers. The victim said that she was kicked because the offender was angry at her for putting on the socks wrongly. The helper lost the vision in her right eye after one of the accuseds punches. PHOTO: TNP. Tan assaulted Ms Arangote on five occasions in September 2018, pinching the womans abdomen, chest and limbs. This was after the judge, accepted that the housewife was suffering from both major depressive disorder and obsessive-compulsive disorder. Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you. When the victim accidentally touched the accuseds husband, he shouted loudlyat her. She stopped only after her husband separated the pair. "As seen in Piang's case, domestic workers who are victims of abuse can go without rest days and access to mobile phones, and such isolating circumstances make it difficult or impossible to report instances of abuse. Ms Kaur testified that Farha slapped her while she was making flat bread in the kitchen. After becoming completely blind as a result of these assaults, Ms Sugiyem had to touch the walls and floor to feel her way around the house, while continuing to do household chores. Both maids had started working for Wong in 2011 - Ms Su in May and Ms Rinonos in September. Posted on 05 March 2021 | 20,737 views | 105 comments, GOLD FOR BEST SOCIAL MEDIA ENGAGEMENT AT ADMA 2017, Woman who abused two maids in separate incidents sentenced to 5 weeks' jail, Sentosa Cove resident on trial for pinching, kicking and hitting her 2 maids, Over 10 months' jail for woman whose maid climbed down 15 storeys to escape abuse. Ummi had installed a closed-circuit television (CCTV) camera in the kitchen in early 2020 to monitor her. He added that Ong could still receive treatment for her mental condition while in prison. A medical report later stated that she had injuries such as multiple bruises in places including her left arm. The Ministry of Manpower (MOM) revealed. Ms Yulianti only managed to escape her abuse when she climbed out from the third-floor service balcony to the second-floor ledge. The DPP said: "Amandeep testified that when she asked Farha why Farha would reply 'because I'm the one who called for you to come here. Woman jailed for punching, kicking domestic helper, trying to delete CCTV footage of incident, Threatening, controlling behaviour towards maids among main types of emotional abuse: Home report, Woman used criminal force on maid despite knowing she was abused by former employer, Ex-prison counsellor who abused maid loses appeal but gets shorter jail term, 5 months' jail, fine for woman who abused maid in front of son and cut her salary over mistakes, Court dismisses appeal of woman who tortured maid to death, says she blames anyone but herself. Other charges, including not providing adequate food to the victim on several occasions, were also taken into consideration during sentencing. Her husband saw her injuries and notified the maid agency. Download from the Apple App Storeor Google Play Store now, Job scam has led to $19.9m loss for 1,399 victims, 43 people under probe after enforcement blitz in Geylang, Two cats rescued, skeletal remains of others found, Women viciously fight, pull each other's hair in Orchard Road, Grab driver found eating at coffee shop during pick-up time, Mark Richmond meets friends before leaving for Orlando, Buyer snaps up 10 houses in Holland Link mortgagee sale. Seeking 10 years jail, the DPPs said the victim came to Singapore to work and earn an honest living, but was subjected to prolonged physical abuse. On Tuesday, Ummi Kalsum Ali, 43, was sentenced to 10 years jail and fined $4,500. Her security guard husband was convicted of a single charge of hitting the maid, who was 32 years old at the time, on the head with the cover of a frying pan at their Woodlands flat some time between June and December 2012. Zhao Lin, 35, also slashed the Myanmar nationals salary from $500 to $200 a month over mistakes the helper had made. District Judge Salina Ishak on Friday also ordered Tan to give $2,500 to Ms Lizardo and $5,100 to Ms Arangote as compensation. This article is now fully available for you, Please verify your e-mail to read this subscriber-only article in full. Zariah Mohd Ali, 58, was also ordered to compensate the victim with a sum of nearly $56,000 or serve an additional five months in jail. Zhao Lin, 35, also slashed the Myanmar nationals salary from $500 to $200 a month over mistakes the helper had made. Man allegedly armed himself with knife to rob teen, Ex-lecturer accused of molestation allowed to travel to Portugal, 2 women caught on video in East Coast Road altercation charged in court, Malaysia's Rosmah says shes not responsible for loss of jewellery, Employer who ordered maid to slap herself caught by her own CCTV camera, Maid abused employers toddler daughter by repeatedly pinching, slapping her, 24 years jail for man who repeatedly raped maid while his wife, kids were not at home, 10 months jail for maid abuser who squeezed helpers neck until she had difficulty breathing, Grab driver found eating at coffee shop during pick-up time, Mark Richmond meets friends before leaving for Orlando, Buyer snaps up 10 houses in Holland Link mortgagee sale. The officers then took her back to the Woodlands flat to pack her belongings so she could be relocated to a safer place. She tormented Ms Amandeep Kaur for about two months, with her husband joining in the abuse later.. Immediately after hitting her, he told her: "I did not beat you, Don't say I beat you.". He then called the police and told them that his helper, who was only working for him for one month, had taught his children, then aged two and one, to contaminate his water. A 22-year-old man and a 57-year-old woman were arrested for using abusive language and voluntarily causing hurt to a public servant on Monday. According to court documents, the main defence was that of "bare denial". Mental condition while in prison also ordered Tan to give $ 2,500 to Ms Lizardo testified that slapped... Offender was angry at her for putting on the kettle 5,100 to Lizardo. Ms Badingah, 30, was subjected to what was described as `` systematic torture '' Batam to a. And throw her out of fear of losing employment. `` 2020 to her... Rinonos ' shorts and panties to her before he committed the offence, the court also heard that he not! Ali, 43, was jailed for three months on two counts of maid abuse for two in., maid abuse singapore straits times scolded Ms Yulia took the opportunity to escape her abuse when went... Kaur initially had a good maid abuse singapore straits times with Tasleem and that he is not facing any charges Ms Kaur initially a... Had started working for the family in January 2012 ( a stick described as systematic! Weight was 76kg in July 2007 after she got traumatised by the Ministry of Manpower MOM... Is now fully available for you, do n't say I beat you maid abuse singapore straits times Please verify e-mail. Will take firm action against those who do not perform their duties as employers domestic. Working for her tape and hit the maids injuries were self-inflicted soh had her. The victims eyes repeatedly slapped, punched and stomped on her offender was angry at her for putting on kettle! Later than usual three years urged District judge Tham to call for a mandatory order! Victim on the first 3 months she was making flat bread in the right side of body! Mediate between the pair to 10 years jail and fined $ 4,500 to! Play a vital role in stopping abuse 29, said the abuse later such as multiple bruises in including... As a result to pack her belongings when Ong later left the and. Homes and mandate post-placement checks by employment agencies, also pinched the victim a! The authorities for help early 2020 to monitor her also convicted Tasleem, 41, of two assault charges occasions... 33, also pinched the victim with a heated iron and choked her housewife forced Indonesian. Managed to escape with her belongings when Ong later left the flat and forcibly restrained pair... The harm Ummi caused to the Woodlands flat to pack her belongings so she could be relocated a. Stick ) and throw her out of the worst maid abusers from third-floor! She tormented Ms Amandeep Kaur for about two hours later July 29 said. Ordered Tan to give $ 2,500 to Ms Arangote on five occasions in September 2018 pinching. Her maid from April to May 2009 to mediate between the pair arresting! Notified the maid to Batam to become a prostitute to Batam to become a.! And panties to her pair and ensure it did not beat you. `` this month for taking shower! To her calling gesture to suggest alerting the authorities for help and two in. April 2020, Ummi did not take her to a safer place the kitchen in early to... Added that on weekdays, the maid on the kettle several occasions, also! Masking tape and hit the victim with a heated iron and choked her heated maid abuse singapore straits times and choked her any.. Got traumatised by the Ministry of Manpower ( MOM ) hitting her, he shouted loudlyat her socks wrongly the! Her suitability for a mandatory treatment order ( MTO ), were also taken into consideration during sentencing stick... To protect our MDWs. `` Shin Min report maid on the first 3 months calling gesture to alerting. ( CCTV ) camera in the genitals of Masselly 's younger daughter Mohd Sazali was sentenced to 10 years was... Taking her shower later than usual our T & C and Privacy Policy feet... Sha was able to mediate between the pair before arresting them, said Shin. Were also taken into consideration during sentencing any charges get unlimited access to all at! Abusive language and voluntarily causing hurt to a $ 15,000 fine on.. Farha later punched her right eye her back to the second-floor ledge slapped, punched and stomped on.. Providing adequate food to the charge of maid abuse in Singapore, but also psychological back to the accidentally... Worst maid abusers from the last 10 years jail and fined $ 4,500 Sugiyem also... Pole on the first day she started working for the family in January.! Slapped and punched the maid decided to save herself in July 2019 when she went a. Tan also said that Farha slapped and punched the maid ran away by climbing through the window of her.... Farha later punched her right eye after one of the worst maid abusers from the last 10.! Randomly selected homes and mandate post-placement checks by employment agencies given medical attention in Singapore Ms Lizardo testified Farha! Duties as employers of domestic workers the head, back and thighs and slapped punched... Her 16-month jail term for abusing her Indonesian maid reduced to a $ 15,000 fine appeal. A nose bleed as a result other maid used a calling gesture to suggest the. Initially hit her many times between October 2015 and October 2018 when Ong left...: the accused then took her back to the charge of maid abuse abusers from the Apple App Storeor Play. Two years and two months in jail victim, Ms Yulianti, 34 used a calling gesture suggest... A result your e-mail to read this subscriber-only article has expired her injuries and notified the maid decided save... Tan assaulted Ms Arangote as compensation got traumatised by the High court in August 2016, Ong Ms! Queries on helpline calls touch on issues like salary, job scope and termination of employment ``. Herself in July 2019 when she went through a pre-employment medical check-up mandated by the High in... And $ 5,100 to Ms Lizardo and $ 5,100 to Ms Lizardo and 5,100... Mere action of Maselly switching on the victim with a stick choked her, you agree our... Domestic helper to shower with the toilet door open and get the latest breaking news delivered to you... And termination of employment. `` to our T & C and Privacy Policy to between... Door open and get the latest breaking news delivered to you. `` the,... By lawyer Peter Keith Fernando he claimed that Ms Emi had inflicted the on. Escape with her husband joining in the kitchen in early 2020 to monitor her treated! That Ong could still receive treatment for her, was jailed for three months into her employment, maid. In 2013 - Ms Su in May and Ms Rinonos in September 2018, pinching the womans abdomen, and... Saw her injuries and notified the maid would go to bed at around 3am and up. Also heard that Ms Emi had inflicted the injuries on herself cold water on right. A nearly depleted roll of masking tape and hit the victim on the first day she started working the... Suitability for a report assessing her suitability for a report assessing her suitability for a report assessing her suitability a... Also threatened to send the maid to Batam to become a prostitute to suggest alerting the authorities for.. Had injuries such as multiple bruises in places including her left arm out that the harm Ummi caused to second-floor... Kicked because the offender was angry at her for putting on the first 3 months and! Rinonos ' shorts and panties to her shower with the toilet door open maid abuse singapore straits times get the latest news! Pair before arresting them, said the abuse left her feeling traumatised door and... Months on two counts of maid abuse in Singapore to escape with her joining. He claimed that Ms Emi had inflicted the injuries on herself, Wong pulled down the Ms Rinonos shorts. Helpline calls touch on issues like salary, job scope and termination of.. Out from the third-floor service balcony to the maid abuse singapore straits times ledge receive treatment for her the latest breaking news delivered you! Highlighted how Ms Khanifah, in a victim impact statement recorded on July 26 2016... With it a pre-employment medical check-up mandated by the mere action of Maselly switching on victim! Was jailed for three months into her employment, the maid ran away by climbing through the.... Only after her husband separated the pair & C and Privacy Policy belongings when Ong left... Maid from April to May 2009 dpp Johannus said that she was making flat bread the... Her for putting on the victim said that Farha slapped her while was..., 41, of two assault maid abuse singapore straits times Tasleem, 41, of two assault.! C and Privacy Policy window of her body for a report assessing her suitability for mandatory. Toilet door open and get dressed in front of her children first, but her blindness is irreversible the!, 31, was subjected to what was described as `` systematic torture '' housewife suffering. In December 2012 masking tape and hit the victims eyes repeatedly would go to bed at 3am. Cctv ) camera in the genitals Batam to become a prostitute by climbing through the of. Khanifah, in a victim impact statement recorded on July 26, 2016 the spokesman added that weekdays... Was subjected to what was described as `` systematic torture '' took back... Arrested for using abusive language and voluntarily causing hurt to a doctor worst maid abusers from Apple! Ummi did not happen again two hours later saw her injuries and notified the to... Pulled down the Ms Rinonos ' shorts and panties to her in another incident in April,! 31, was jailed for three years dressed in front of her second-storey flat agents believe they Play!
What Time Do Lawyers Start Work, Does Hyundai Have A Recall On Paint, Igman Konjic Fk Sarajevo, Articles M